On paper, Marcus Stroman appears to be precisely what the New York Yankees require. The Yankees officially signed Stroman on Thursday for a two-year deal worth $37 million.

The contract additionally incorporates a player option for 2026 valued at $18 million, contingent on him pitching 140 innings in 2025. This acquisition provides the Yankees with another reliable arm in the rotation, positioned after Gerrit Cole to offer stability.

The Yankees’ interest in Stroman is evident, given his consistent presence on the mound every fifth day, consistently delivering six solid innings per start.

His 56.6% ground ball rate aligns well with the home run-prone environment of Yankee Stadium. At 32 years old, Stroman also brings a spirited element to a team that, at times, may seem rather mechanical. His presence alongside younger players adds vitality to the roster.

Stroman’s fiery demeanor, while adding a dynamic element, also has the potential to lead to trouble. Known for being outspoken and occasionally controversial on social media, he has been noted for his liberal use of the block function.

Stroman had previously criticized the Yankees’ pitching staff, a move that didn’t sit well with the fan base, particularly in response to general manager Brian Cashman’s remark that he “was not a difference-maker.”

Concerns about Stroman extend to his on-field performance. His track record at Yankee Stadium is less than stellar, marked by a 6.06 ERA and a 1.635 WHiP in his new home, representing his worst statistics at any ballpark where he has made more than two appearances. While the challenges there might be influenced by facing the Yankees, it remains a point of concern.

Despite potential risks, signing Stroman was a necessary move for the Yankees. He stood out as one of the better pitchers in the free-agent market, and addressing their rotation was imperative. The acquisition of Juan Soto underscored the team’s commitment to the current season, a stance that couldn’t be maintained with their existing rotation.

While there is a possibility that adding Stroman could turn out to be a disaster, the Yankees found themselves in a position where they needed him. However, as the saying goes, one must exercise caution about what they wish for.